Arbitrage vs co-hosting vs STR property management: which is right for your property?

Real estate investors increasingly partner with short-term rental operators instead of managing rentals themselves or settling for a long-term tenant. There are three ways those partnerships are structured: arbitrage, co-hosting, and STR property management.

• Arbitrage: fixed rent, zero involvement. You get a predictable rent check that doesn't move with occupancy or season, but you don't participate in the upside if the listing performs exceptionally well.
• Co-hosting: you own the listing, you keep the upside. You earn far more than a fixed rent check when the property performs, but your income now moves with occupancy and season.
• STR property management: hands-off, operator-held. The lightest-touch option for you, but you give up direct control of the listing and the guest relationship.
• You list your investment property for free and stay in full control of who contacts you. The listing marks your property as STR-friendly and Airbnb-approved to every operator browsing, whichever of the three models you're open to.

Common questions

What's the difference between co-hosting and STR property management?

Both split short-term rental revenue with no rent, on similar terms. The difference is who owns the listing. In co-hosting, you keep the Airbnb account and the operator runs it for you. In property management, the operator owns and runs the listing themselves. Co-hosting keeps you in control of the asset; property management hands the whole operation over.

Do I pay the operator anything in an arbitrage deal?

No. In arbitrage the money flows the other way: the operator pays you rent, furnishes the property at their own cost (typically 8,000 to 15,000 dollars), and keeps the short-term rental income. You're the landlord, not the one paying.

What percentage does an STR co-host or property manager take?

Typically 15 to 35 percent of revenue, depending on the property, the market, and the scope of work. Whether the split is calculated before or after cleaning costs is negotiable.

Who pays for furnishing in an STR partnership?

It depends on the model. In arbitrage, the operator furnishes the property because they keep the income. In co-hosting and property management, furnishing is usually the owner's cost, since the owner keeps the larger share of revenue. All of it is negotiable.

Which model makes the most money for the owner?

Co-hosting and property management have the higher ceiling, because you keep the upside of strong short-term rental performance. Arbitrage has the higher floor, because you collect rent whether the listing books well or not. The right choice depends on whether you want certainty or upside.

Is it safe to rent my property to a short-term rental operator?

A good operator treats your property as a business asset, since their income depends on it performing and staying in good condition. The risk is in who you partner with, not the model itself, which is why vetting the operator before you commit matters more than which structure you choose.

About Vantage

Vantage is the STR marketplace where owners find operators and operators find owners. One platform, every partnership model, every step from first look to signed. Visit Vantage or see how it works.

View this page on Vantage.